Files
sundynix-agentix/sundynix-dispatcher/internal/eino/graph.go
T
Blizzard 16a6c4b1aa feat(hitl): 人工审批中断(Eino Phase D)—— 审批节点暂停→批准续跑/拒绝中止
专用「审批」节点方案,全栈打通。

后端:
- contract:TaskWaiting/TaskRejected 状态 + ApprovalSubject/ApprovalDecision。
- bus:PublishApproval + WaitApproval(订阅决定主题,带超时);消费者 AckWait
  30s→15min(阻塞等人审期间消息未 ack,否则重投成重复任务)。
- dispatcher:ApprovalWaiter 接口 + approvalNode——执行到审批节点发 await 事件 +
  置 waiting,阻塞等决定。批准→回 running 放行下游;拒绝/超时→errRejected 哨兵→
  剪下游→rejected,优雅收尾不计熔断。超时安全默认拒绝。
  taskExecTimeout 3→10min(审批5 < 执行10 < AckWait15)。
- 网关:POST /tasks/:id/approve(仅 waiting 态受理,幂等)。

桌面端:
- Studio 新增「人工审批」节点(nodeCatalog,可填标题/说明)。
- run.ts pendingApproval() 从 exec 流派生待审中断 + waiting 节点状态。
- BottomDrawer ApprovalBar:琥珀审批条(摘要 + 批准/拒绝 + 备注,调 api.approveTask)。
- ExecTrace waiting 状态灯。

验证:后端 curl 实测 waiting→批准→running→done;waiting→拒绝→rejected(下游未跑)。
前端 tsc + vitest 36 过(pendingApproval 4 例 + waiting 状态)。全模块 build+vet+test 全绿。
EINO_ADOPTION Phase D 标记 HITL 完成。

未覆盖:compose 路径(EINO_COMPOSE,默认关)的 approval 节点;桌面端审批条未在 GUI 实点。

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-24 13:18:47 +08:00

554 lines
18 KiB
Go
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
package eino
import (
"context"
"fmt"
"strconv"
"strings"
"time"
"github.com/cloudwego/eino/schema"
"go.opentelemetry.io/otel/attribute"
"go.opentelemetry.io/otel/trace"
"github.com/sundynix/sundynix-dispatcher/internal/dsl"
"github.com/sundynix/sundynix-dispatcher/internal/harness"
"github.com/sundynix/sundynix-shared/contract"
"github.com/sundynix/sundynix-shared/otelx"
)
// defaultAgentSystem 是 agent 节点未填系统提示词时的兜底。
const defaultAgentSystem = "你是 sundynix-agentix 平台的 AI 助手。"
// board 是图执行的"黑板":节点按拓扑序流转时读写它。
type board struct {
uid, sid string
query string
profile string
history []*schema.Message
kb string // 最近一个检索节点的 owner 作用域库名(供 map 并行各项检索)
refs []string // 检索 / 聚合得到的参考资料
toolOut []string // 工具节点产出
sections []reportSection // map 并行 fan-out 产出的分项成稿(供 render 多章渲染)
answer string // 当前成稿(多 agent 协作时 = 最近一个 agent 的产出 = 成品)
agentOut []string // 各上游 agent 的产出(按序),注入下游 agent 上下文以实现接力协作
rejected bool // HITL 审批节点拒绝/超时 → 置位,runGraph 中止并返回 errRejected
}
// runGraph 按 DSL 图的真实拓扑与连线执行(替代旧的线性拍平 compileFlow)。
//
// 入度0 入口 → 沿连线传播 active → 每个节点按 kind 执行真实行为 →
// branch 按条件只激活选中的下游(剪枝)→ agent 节点流式回流 token。
//
// 逐节点点亮"运行·观测"。返回终端 agent 的完整产出(供写回历史)。
func (o *Orchestrator) runGraph(ctx context.Context, t *contract.Task, tr *execTracer) (string, error) {
flow, ferr := dsl.Parse(t.Graph)
plan := dsl.Compile(t.Graph)
b := &board{
uid: meta(t, contract.MetaUserID),
sid: meta(t, contract.MetaSessionID),
query: plan.Query,
}
// 无法解析或空图:退化为"无图单轮对话"(注入默认记忆 + 直接出模型)。
if ferr != nil || flow == nil || len(flow.Nodes) == 0 {
tr.info("task", "system", "无结构化图", "按单轮对话执行")
b.profile = o.fetchMemory(ctx, b.uid, b.query)
b.history = o.fetchHistory(ctx, b.sid)
o.runConversation(ctx, t.ID, b, plan.System, tr, "agent")
return b.answer, nil
}
// 建邻接与入度(只认两端都存在的边)。保留整条边以便 branch 按 true/false 标签选路。
nodeByID := make(map[string]dsl.Node, len(flow.Nodes))
outE := make(map[string][]dsl.Edge)
indeg := make(map[string]int, len(flow.Nodes))
for _, n := range flow.Nodes {
nodeByID[n.ID] = n
indeg[n.ID] = 0
}
for _, e := range flow.Edges {
if _, ok := nodeByID[e.Source]; !ok {
continue
}
if _, ok := nodeByID[e.Target]; !ok {
continue
}
outE[e.Source] = append(outE[e.Source], e)
indeg[e.Target]++
}
// 入口节点(入度 0)置 active;执行时沿连线把下游激活,branch 只激活选中分支。
active := make(map[string]bool)
for _, n := range flow.Nodes {
if indeg[n.ID] == 0 {
active[n.ID] = true
}
}
// 图里没有 memory 节点 → 沿用旧默认:注入画像+历史(避免回归)。
hasMemory := false
for _, n := range flow.Nodes {
if n.Kind == "memory" {
hasMemory = true
break
}
}
if !hasMemory {
b.profile = o.fetchMemory(ctx, b.uid, b.query)
b.history = o.fetchHistory(ctx, b.sid)
}
for _, n := range flow.Topo() {
if !active[n.ID] {
continue // 被 branch 剪掉的下游,不执行
}
// 每个节点一个 span:下游的工具调用 / LLM span 会自动挂到本节点之下,
// Jaeger 里即呈现「节点 → 工具 → embedding/milvus」的层级。
nctx, nspan := otelx.Tracer().Start(ctx, "node."+n.Kind,
trace.WithAttributes(
attribute.String("sundynix.node.id", n.ID),
attribute.String("sundynix.node.kind", n.Kind),
))
propagate := targetsOf(outE[n.ID]) // 默认激活全部出边;branch 会改写
switch n.Kind {
case "input":
if txt := cstr(n.Config, "text"); txt != "" {
b.query = txt
}
tr.info("input:"+n.ID, "system", labelOf(n, "输入"), truncate(b.query, 80))
case "memory":
if cbool(n.Config, "profile") {
b.profile = o.fetchMemory(nctx, b.uid, b.query)
}
if cbool(n.Config, "history") {
b.history = o.fetchHistory(nctx, b.sid)
}
tr.info("memory:"+n.ID, "memory", labelOf(n, "记忆"),
fmt.Sprintf("画像 %d 字 · 历史 %d 条", len([]rune(b.profile)), len(b.history)))
case "retriever":
o.retrieverNode(nctx, n, b, tr)
case "tool":
o.execToolNode(nctx, t.ID, n, b, tr)
case "agent":
sys := firstNonEmpty(cstr(n.Config, "system"), plan.System)
if cbool(n.Config, "autonomous") { // 开启自主工具 → ReAct(模型自己选工具)
o.runReactAgent(nctx, t.ID, b, sys, n, tr, "agent:"+n.ID)
} else {
o.runConversation(nctx, t.ID, b, sys, tr, "agent:"+n.ID)
}
case "aggregate":
merged := aggregate(cstr(n.Config, "strategy"), append(append([]string{}, b.refs...), b.toolOut...))
b.refs, b.toolOut = merged, nil
tr.info("aggregate:"+n.ID, "system", labelOf(n, "汇聚"), "策略:"+firstNonEmpty(cstr(n.Config, "strategy"), "拼接"))
case "render":
o.renderNode(nctx, t.ID, n, b, tr)
case "branch":
propagate = o.branchNode(n, b, outE[n.ID], nodeByID, tr)
case "approval":
propagate = o.approvalNode(nctx, t.ID, n, b, tr, outE[n.ID])
case "map":
o.mapNode(nctx, t.ID, n, b, tr)
case "output":
tr.info("output:"+n.ID, "system", labelOf(n, "输出"), "目标:"+firstNonEmpty(cstr(n.Config, "target"), "屏幕"))
default:
tr.info(n.Kind+":"+n.ID, "system", labelOf(n, n.Kind), "未识别节点,跳过")
}
nspan.End()
if b.rejected {
break // 审批拒绝/超时:中止后续节点,整图判 rejected
}
for _, tgt := range propagate {
active[tgt] = true
}
}
if b.rejected {
return b.answer, errRejected // 合法终态,Handle 据此判 rejected 并优雅收尾
}
// 图里无 agent 节点(纯工具/检索图)也要出一段模型答复,否则没有输出。
if b.answer == "" {
o.runConversation(ctx, t.ID, b, plan.System, tr, "agent")
}
return b.answer, nil
}
// retrieverNode 执行检索节点:kb 按 owner 作用域 → kb_search → 累计参考资料。
func (o *Orchestrator) retrieverNode(ctx context.Context, n dsl.Node, b *board, tr *execTracer) {
kb := cstr(n.Config, "kb")
scoped := kb
if b.uid != "" && kb != "" && !strings.Contains(kb, "/") {
scoped = b.uid + "/" + kb
}
if scoped != "" {
b.kb = scoped // 记下作用域库名,供后续 map 并行各项检索复用
}
end := tr.span("retriever:"+n.ID, "tool", labelOf(n, "检索"))
refs := o.retrieve(ctx, scoped, b.query)
if refs != "" {
b.refs = append(b.refs, refs)
}
end(fmt.Sprintf("kb=%s · 命中 %d 段", firstNonEmpty(kb, "(未指定)"), countLines(refs)), nil)
}
// mapNode 执行并行 fan-out:把主题拆成若干项,各项有界并发撰写(复用 report 的 writeSections),
// 成稿存入黑板(结构化 sections + 拼进 answer),并流式呈现进度。
func (o *Orchestrator) mapNode(ctx context.Context, taskID string, n dsl.Node, b *board, tr *execTracer) {
end := tr.span("map:"+n.ID, "plan", labelOf(n, "并行 fan-out"))
items := o.planItems(ctx, b.query, cstr(n.Config, "splitBy"))
end(fmt.Sprintf("拆出 %d 项:%s", len(items), strings.Join(items, " / ")), nil)
o.emit(taskID, fmt.Sprintf("\n> 并行处理 %d 项…\n\n", len(items)))
secs := o.writeSections(ctx, b.query, b.kb, items, tr) // 有界并发,trace 出 section:i 各项
b.sections = secs
for _, s := range secs {
chunk := "## " + s.Heading + "\n\n" + s.Body + "\n\n"
o.emit(taskID, chunk)
b.answer += chunk
b.refs = append(b.refs, s.Heading+""+s.Body)
}
}
// execToolNode 执行工具节点:调 MCP 工具,产出累计进黑板;失败降级不阻断。
func (o *Orchestrator) execToolNode(ctx context.Context, taskID string, n dsl.Node, b *board, tr *execTracer) {
tool, args := dsl.ToolBinding(n)
if tool == "" {
return
}
node := "tool:" + tool
if o.tools == nil {
tr.info(node, "tool", "工具 "+tool, "工具总线未接入,跳过")
return
}
call := map[string]any{}
for k, v := range args {
call[k] = v
}
if call["q"] == nil && call["query"] == nil {
call["q"] = b.query
}
if b.uid != "" {
if kbv, ok := call["kb"].(string); ok && kbv != "" && !strings.Contains(kbv, "/") {
call["kb"] = b.uid + "/" + kbv
}
}
end := tr.span(node, "tool", "调用工具 "+tool)
cctx, cancel := context.WithTimeout(ctx, toolCallTimeout)
defer cancel()
res, err := o.tools.CallTool(cctx, contract.ToolSubjectGo(tool), &contract.ToolCall{Tool: tool, TaskID: taskID, Args: call})
if err != nil {
end("调用失败,降级跳过", err)
return
}
if res == nil || !res.OK || res.Content == "" {
end("无结果,降级跳过", nil)
return
}
end("入参 "+previewArgs(call)+" → 产出 "+truncate(res.Content, 160), nil)
b.toolOut = append(b.toolOut, "["+tool+"] "+res.Content)
}
// runAgent 执行 agent/模型节点:据黑板拼消息 → 流式回流 token → 累计成稿。
func (o *Orchestrator) runAgent(ctx context.Context, taskID string, b *board, system string, tr *execTracer, node string) {
rc := &RunCtx{
System: firstNonEmpty(system, defaultAgentSystem),
Query: b.query,
Profile: b.profile,
History: b.history,
ToolOut: append(append([]string{}, b.toolOut...), b.refs...),
Upstream: append([]string{}, b.agentOut...), // 前序协作 agent 产出 → 接力
}
msgs, _ := buildMessages(ctx, rc)
tr.emit(node, "model", "start", "模型流式推理", "", 0)
t0 := time.Now()
n, redacted := 0, 0
var produced strings.Builder // 本节点自身产出(用于沿图向下游传递)
send := func(s string) {
if s == "" {
return
}
// 输出护栏:发射前逐片脱敏疑似密钥/令牌(流式无法回收已发,故逐片处理)。
safe, hit := harness.RedactSecrets(s)
redacted += hit
_ = o.sink.PublishToken(taskID, []byte(safe))
produced.WriteString(safe)
n++
}
var err error
if o.pool.Ready() {
err = o.pool.ChatStream(ctx, toChatMessages(msgs), send)
} else {
err = o.pool.StreamText(ctx, replyFor(msgs), func(tok []byte) { send(string(tok)) })
}
if err != nil {
tr.emit(node, "model", "error", "模型流式推理", err.Error(), time.Since(t0).Milliseconds())
return
}
if redacted > 0 {
tr.info(node, "system", "输出护栏", fmt.Sprintf("已脱敏 %d 处疑似密钥/令牌", redacted))
}
o.recordAgentOutput(b, produced.String()) // 产出入黑板:成当前成稿 + 供下游接力
tr.emit(node, "model", "end", "模型流式推理",
fmt.Sprintf("%d tokens / %d 字", n, len([]rune(produced.String()))), time.Since(t0).Milliseconds())
}
// recordAgentOutput 把一个 agent 节点的产出记入黑板:append 到 agentOut(供下游 agent 注入接力),
// 并设为当前成稿 answer(多 agent 协作时,最后一个 agent 的产出即最终成品)。空产出忽略。
func (o *Orchestrator) recordAgentOutput(b *board, out string) {
if strings.TrimSpace(out) == "" {
return
}
b.agentOut = append(b.agentOut, out)
b.answer = out
}
// renderNode 执行渲染节点:把当前成稿渲染成 Word(经 mcp-go report_render)。
func (o *Orchestrator) renderNode(ctx context.Context, taskID string, n dsl.Node, b *board, tr *execTracer) {
if strings.TrimSpace(b.answer) == "" {
tr.info("render:"+n.ID, "render", labelOf(n, "渲染"), "暂无正文可渲染(render 前需有 agent 产出)")
return
}
format := firstNonEmpty(cstr(n.Config, "format"), "docx")
end := tr.span("render:"+n.ID, "render", labelOf(n, "渲染 "+format))
title := truncate(b.query, 40)
secs := b.sections // map 产出的多章优先;否则把整段成稿当单章
if len(secs) == 0 {
secs = []reportSection{{Heading: title, Body: b.answer}}
}
if path := o.renderReport(ctx, taskID, title, secs); path != "" {
end("已落盘:"+path, nil)
o.emit(taskID, "\n\n---\n✅ 已渲染 "+format+" 文档,可在「下载」获取。\n")
} else {
end("渲染服务不可用", fmt.Errorf("render unavailable"))
}
}
// branchNode 执行分支节点:求值条件,按出边的 true/false 标签选出要激活的下游。
// 边带 sourceHandle("true"/"false") 时按标签精确选路(前端 Phase 2 给 branch 的边打标);
// 无标签的旧图退回"出边顺序 [true,false]"约定,保持向后兼容。
func (o *Orchestrator) branchNode(n dsl.Node, b *board, outs []dsl.Edge, byID map[string]dsl.Node, tr *execTracer) []string {
cond := cstr(n.Config, "condition")
res := evalCondition(cond, b)
var truthy, falsy []string
labeled := false
for _, e := range outs {
switch e.SourceHandle {
case "true":
truthy = append(truthy, e.Target)
labeled = true
case "false":
falsy = append(falsy, e.Target)
labeled = true
}
}
var chosen []string
mode := "边标签"
if labeled {
if res {
chosen = truthy
} else {
chosen = falsy
}
} else {
mode = "边序约定[true,false]"
targets := targetsOf(outs)
switch {
case len(targets) >= 2:
if res {
chosen = targets[:1]
} else {
chosen = targets[1:2]
}
case len(targets) == 1 && !res:
chosen = nil
default:
chosen = targets
}
}
names := make([]string, 0, len(chosen))
for _, id := range chosen {
names = append(names, labelOf(byID[id], id))
}
tr.info("branch:"+n.ID, "system", labelOf(n, "分支"),
fmt.Sprintf("条件「%s」→ %v ⇒ 走 [%s]%s",
firstNonEmpty(cond, "(空=真)"), res, strings.Join(names, ", "), mode))
return chosen
}
// approvalNode 是 HITL 人工审批中断:执行到此暂停,把待审摘要推给 UI(exec 事件 kind=approval/phase=await
// + 状态 waiting),阻塞等人工批准/拒绝(带超时,安全默认拒绝)。
// 批准 → 状态回 running 并放行下游;拒绝/超时 → 置 b.rejected 中止全图。返回应激活的下游(拒绝=空)。
func (o *Orchestrator) approvalNode(ctx context.Context, taskID string, n dsl.Node, b *board, tr *execTracer, outs []dsl.Edge) []string {
title := firstNonEmpty(cstr(n.Config, "title"), labelOf(n, "人工审批"))
prompt := firstNonEmpty(cstr(n.Config, "prompt"), "请审批是否继续执行后续步骤")
summary := prompt
if b.answer != "" { // 带上当前产出预览,便于审批人判断
summary = prompt + "\n—— 当前产出预览 ——\n" + truncate(b.answer, 400)
}
// 未接审批通道(单测/降级)→ 自动放行,避免无人应答卡死。
if o.approval == nil {
tr.info("approval:"+n.ID, "approval", title, "未接审批通道,自动放行")
return targetsOf(outs)
}
// 暂停:发待审事件(UI 据 kind=approval & phase=await 弹批准/拒绝)+ 置任务 waiting。
tr.emit("approval:"+n.ID, "approval", "await", title, summary, 0)
o.setStatus(taskID, contract.TaskWaiting, title)
dec, err := o.approval.WaitApproval(ctx, taskID, approvalTimeout)
switch {
case err != nil: // 超时 / ctx 取消 → 安全默认拒绝
b.rejected = true
b.answer = "❌ 审批超时未决,已自动拒绝:" + title
tr.emit("approval:"+n.ID, "approval", "error", title, "审批超时,自动拒绝", 0)
return nil
case !dec.Approved:
b.rejected = true
note := firstNonEmpty(dec.Note, "审批人拒绝")
b.answer = "❌ 已被拒绝:" + note
tr.emit("approval:"+n.ID, "approval", "end", title, "拒绝:"+note, 0)
return nil
default: // 批准 → 恢复执行,放行下游
o.setStatus(taskID, contract.TaskRunning, "审批通过,继续执行")
tr.emit("approval:"+n.ID, "approval", "end", title, "批准:"+firstNonEmpty(dec.Note, "放行"), 0)
return targetsOf(outs)
}
}
// targetsOf 取一组边的目标节点 ID(保持顺序)。
func targetsOf(edges []dsl.Edge) []string {
out := make([]string, 0, len(edges))
for _, e := range edges {
out = append(out, e.Target)
}
return out
}
// evalCondition 求值 branch 条件。支持:
//
// 空 → true;关键字 refs/tools/answer/profile 作左值(取数量/字数);
// 形如 "a op b"op: >= <= == != > <)数值比较;其余非空 → 默认真。
func evalCondition(cond string, b *board) bool {
cond = strings.TrimSpace(cond)
if cond == "" {
return true
}
for _, op := range []string{">=", "<=", "==", "!=", ">", "<"} {
if i := strings.Index(cond, op); i >= 0 {
l := resolveOperand(strings.TrimSpace(cond[:i]), b)
r := resolveOperand(strings.TrimSpace(cond[i+len(op):]), b)
switch op {
case ">":
return l > r
case "<":
return l < r
case ">=":
return l >= r
case "<=":
return l <= r
case "==":
return l == r
case "!=":
return l != r
}
}
}
return true
}
// resolveOperand 把条件里的左/右值解析为数值(关键字取运行时数量,否则按字面量)。
func resolveOperand(s string, b *board) float64 {
switch strings.ToLower(s) {
case "refs":
return float64(len(b.refs))
case "tools":
return float64(len(b.toolOut))
case "answer":
return float64(len([]rune(b.answer)))
case "profile":
return float64(len([]rune(b.profile)))
}
f, _ := strconv.ParseFloat(s, 64)
return f
}
// aggregate 按策略合并多段参考资料为一段。
func aggregate(strategy string, parts []string) []string {
var nonEmpty []string
for _, p := range parts {
if strings.TrimSpace(p) != "" {
nonEmpty = append(nonEmpty, p)
}
}
if len(nonEmpty) == 0 {
return nil
}
switch strategy {
case "去重合并":
seen := map[string]bool{}
var uniq []string
for _, p := range nonEmpty {
if !seen[p] {
seen[p] = true
uniq = append(uniq, p)
}
}
return []string{strings.Join(uniq, "\n---\n")}
case "摘要":
return []string{truncate(strings.Join(nonEmpty, "\n"), 800)}
default: // 拼接
return []string{strings.Join(nonEmpty, "\n---\n")}
}
}
// ---- 小工具 ----
func meta(t *contract.Task, key string) string {
v, _ := t.Meta[key].(string)
return v
}
func cstr(cfg map[string]any, key string) string {
if cfg == nil {
return ""
}
v, ok := cfg[key]
if !ok || v == nil {
return ""
}
if s, ok := v.(string); ok {
return strings.TrimSpace(s)
}
return strings.TrimSpace(fmt.Sprint(v))
}
func cbool(cfg map[string]any, key string) bool {
if cfg == nil {
return false
}
if v, ok := cfg[key].(bool); ok {
return v
}
return false
}
func labelOf(n dsl.Node, def string) string {
if strings.TrimSpace(n.Label) != "" {
return n.Label
}
return def
}
func countLines(s string) int {
s = strings.TrimSpace(s)
if s == "" {
return 0
}
return strings.Count(s, "\n") + 1
}